Guitar picks might seem small, but they make a big difference in shaping your sound and style. Whether you’re just starting out or have been playing for years, finding the right pick can change the way you play and feel about your music.
There’s a whole world of picks to explore. They come in different materials like classic plastic or bold metals, with all sorts of shapes and sizes. Each one affects your tone, comfort, and technique in a unique way. Many guitarists get pretty particular about their picks because even the smallest changes can have a big impact on their sound.
Some picks are designed for fast and precise playing, which is great if you’re into speed. Others have a softer touch, perfect for smooth strumming. With so many choices out there, finding the one that feels just right can be a little overwhelming.
In this guide, we’re sharing the best guitar picks of 2024. We have options for every style, skill level, and budget, from affordable picks to premium options.
We’ll walk you through our favorites, what makes each one stand out, and the key things to keep in mind when choosing your pick. By the end, you’ll have a better idea of which pick might be the perfect match for your playing style.
Quick List of the Top Guitar Picks
- Dunlop Tortex Yellow Picks – Best Overall Pick
- D’Addario Chris Thile Casein Pick – Best Guitar Picks for Acoustic Guitar
- Dunlop Kirk Hammett Jazz III Picks – Best Guitar Picks for Shredding
- Dunlop Primetone Grip Picks – Best Guitar Picks for Strumming
- ChickenPicks Badazz III – Best Guitar Picks for Jazz
- Fender Wavelength Picks – Best Guitar Picks for Rock
- Ernie Ball Everlast Picks – Best Guitar Picks for Beginners
- Dunlop Jazz III XL Picks – Best Guitar Picks for Electric Guitar
- Dava Delrin Grip Tips – Best Grip Guitar Picks
- D’Addario Celluloid Picks – Best Budget Pick
Why Guitarists Are Particular About Picks
If you’re a guitarist, you know we can get pretty picky about our picks. And honestly, it makes sense. These little tools might seem small, but they make a huge difference in how we play and how we sound.
First, there’s the material. It actually changes the tone. Nylon picks give you a soft, warm sound. Metal picks bring out a brighter, sharper tone. Plastic ones sit right in between, offering a nice balance that works for a lot of styles.
Then there’s thickness. Thin picks are flexible and perfect for strumming. They give you that easy, flowing feel. But if you want more control, especially for detailed lead playing, thick picks might be the way to go.
Shape matters too. A triangle pick, for example, gives you three different tips you can use, which can come in handy. Jazz III picks are smaller with a sharp point that makes it easy to play fast and precise.
Your musical style also plays a big part in what pick you choose. Heavy metal guitarists tend to go for thicker picks for that strong and aggressive sound. Folk players, on the other hand, might prefer something thin and flexible.
Even the grip makes a difference. Some picks have textured surfaces or little holes to help you hold on better, while others are smooth and make it easy to slide over the strings.
Honestly, we go through a lot of picks before we find the one that feels just right. Even small differences can change how you play or how you connect with your sound.
And as we grow as musicians, our preferences change too. The pick we loved as a beginner might not feel quite right as we improve and try new things.
Trying out different picks is just part of the fun. It’s a simple way to shake up our playing and maybe even find a new favorite sound.
Best Guitar Picks
After testing countless guitar picks, we’ve rounded up the best of the best. Our list has something for every style and skill level, so you can find the perfect pick to take your playing up a notch and bring out your guitar’s full potential.
Dunlop Tortex Yellow Picks
These picks are a solid choice for any guitarist who wants durability, a strong grip, and a great tone.
Pros
- Exceptional durability
- Grip-enhancing matte surface
- Bright, punchy sound
Cons
- May be too thin for some players
- Limited color options
- Slightly more expensive than basic picks
With a thickness of 0.73mm, the Dunlop Tortex Yellow hits that perfect balance. It’s thick enough for a strong, full sound but still thin enough to make strumming quick and easy.
The matte surface is a standout feature. You can play with confidence, knowing the pick isn’t going to slip. This alone gives it an edge over many other picks out there.
These picks offer a bright, punchy sound that cuts through beautifully, whether you’re on an electric or an acoustic. Their standard shape is versatile, allowing for both sharp picking and smooth strumming.
We’ve noticed they hold up much longer than cheaper alternatives, which makes them a great value, even with the slightly higher price.
It’s no surprise that many top musicians swear by these picks. They deliver a professional-quality playing experience that’s hard to beat. Whether you’re just starting out or have been playing for years, these picks are definitely worth a try.
D’Addario Chris Thile Casein Pick
If you’re serious about your guitar or mandolin playing and want a pick that delivers a truly high-end experience, this one is definitely worth checking out.
Pros
- Warm, balanced tone
- Comfortable triangular shape
- Durable casein material
Cons
- Higher price point
- Might take some getting used to
- Limited color options
The Chris Thile Signature Casein Pick is made from casein, a material known for its warm and rich tone. It has that classic feel and sound of a tortoiseshell pick without any ethical issues, which makes it a unique choice.
The triangular shape feels great in your hand and gives you plenty of control. The beveled edges let you pick and strum smoothly, and it practically glides over the strings. Fast playing feels easier with this pick, which is a huge plus if you like quick, detailed passages.
At 1.44mm, it’s definitely on the thicker side, which helps bring out a warmer tone and adds some depth to your dynamics. We noticed that it gives your sound a nice clarity, especially on acoustic instruments. Yes, it’s an investment, but the quality and longevity make it well worth it for players who are serious about their tone.
Dunlop Kirk Hammett Jazz III Picks
If you’re after precision and control in your playing, these Kirk Hammett Jazz III picks are definitely worth a shot.
Pros
- Superior grip with V-shaped cutout
- Excellent for fast, accurate playing
- Designed by Metallica’s lead guitarist
Cons
- Smaller size that might take some time to get used to
- Limited color options
- Slightly pricier than standard picks
The V-shaped cutout in these picks gives you a strong grip, so there’s no slipping, even when you’re hitting those intense solos.
The Kirk Hammett Jazz III picks are just right for shredding. We noticed a boost in both speed and accuracy almost immediately. With the smaller size, you can switch between strings so smoothly, which is a big help for faster playing.
The thickness of the pick brings a clear, bright tone that works beautifully for both lead and rhythm parts. There’s also less pick noise, so your sound has that extra bit of clarity.
Yes, the smaller size took some getting used to, but once we did, we wouldn’t go back. The control it gives us is absolutely worth the quick adjustment. These picks have honestly become our first choice for gigs and recording sessions.
The green color also looks pretty cool on stage, and it’s easy to spot if you happen to drop one. Plus, the 6-pack means you’ll always have spares ready.
If you’re a Metallica fan, playing with Kirk’s signature pick is a pretty awesome feeling. But even if you’re not, these picks totally hold their own and have made a real difference in our playing.
Dunlop Primetone Grip Picks
If you’re after a pick that brings out the best in tone and comfort, Dunlop Primetone picks are a fantastic choice.
Pros
- Excellent grip prevents slipping
- Durable Ultex material lasts long
- Sculpted edges for smooth playing
Cons
- Pricier than basic picks
- Might feel a bit thick if you prefer thinner picks
- Limited color options
These Dunlop Primetone picks have hand-burnished edges that make playing feel super smooth. No more of that annoying snagging on the strings.
At 1.5mm thick, they feel solid in your hand and give a rich, full tone. The low-profile grip really keeps the pick in place, even when you’re in the middle of a fast solo. You can say goodbye to slipping or fumbling mid-play.
The Ultex material is seriously durable. These picks keep their shape and don’t wear down quickly. We’ve put ours through months of heavy playing, and they’re still in great condition.
And the tone? It’s clear and vibrant. Each note rings out with sharp definition, from bright highs to deep lows. It almost feels like you’re hearing your guitar with new clarity.
While they cost a bit more than basic picks, we think the quality makes it well worth it. These picks could easily become your new favorites, whether you’re just practicing or playing live.
ChickenPicks Badazz III
If you’re a serious guitarist looking to boost your precision and get a clearer sound, the ChickenPicks Badazz III might be just what you need.
Pros
- Bright, clear tone with solid bottom-end
- Comfortable grip and easy playability
- Durable thermosetting plastic material
Cons
- Pricey compared to standard picks
- May take time to adjust to the unique shape
- Not ideal for all playing styles
The ChickenPicks Badazz III has a solid 2.0mm thickness that feels just right. It is sturdy without being too heavy. The beveled edges really add to the comfort, making it easy to play both fast and accurately. Honestly, we noticed ourselves playing much smoother with this pick compared to the standard ones.
The sound quality is where these picks really stands out. It delivers a bright, clear tone that cuts through nicely, with a strong low end that adds serious depth. You’ll definitely hear the difference if you’re used to budget picks.
These picks are also built to last. Even after weeks of heavy use, ours still looked and felt almost brand new. The durable material helps reduce any drag, giving you better control over your sound and the way it feels to play.
One thing to consider is the price. These picks are an investment, but if you’re serious about getting great tone and playability, they’re worth every penny.
The unique shape might take a bit of getting used to, especially if you’re familiar with standard picks, but once you’re comfortable, it’s perfect for precise playing.
We found the ChickenPicks Badazz III is ideal for lead work and fast playing. It might not be the best fit for heavy strumming or certain acoustic styles, so it’s worth considering your playing style before switching.
Overall, we’re really impressed with the ChickenPicks Badazz III. If you’re looking to take your tone and technique up a notch, this pick could be just what you need.
Fender Wavelength Picks
If you’re looking for a pick that combines comfort, grip, and that classic Fender tone, the Fender Wavelength picks are a solid choice.
Pros
- Excellent grip pattern
- Warm, rounded tone
- Made in the USA
Cons
- Limited color options
- May be pricey for some
- Only available in 351 shape
The grip pattern on these Fender Wavelength picks is a real game-changer. The debossed texture helps keep the pick securely in place, even during long practice sessions. We found ourselves dropping it a lot less often, which definitely makes playing smoother and more fun.
Made from celluloid, these picks have that familiar feel many guitarists love. They give off a warm, rounded tone that works well across different styles. Whether you’re strumming on an acoustic or rocking out on an electric, these picks give you a sound you can rely on.
Fender also offers these picks in various thicknesses, which is a nice touch. We tried the medium gauge, which gives a good mix of flexibility and control. The tortoise shell design looks really classy too, although we do wish there were more colors to choose from.
All in all, the Fender Wavelength picks are a great choice if you want dependable grip, warm tone, and a touch of that classic Fender feel.
Ernie Ball Everlast Picks
If you’re after a pick that’s both tough and comfortable, the Ernie Ball Everlast picks are definitely worth a look.
Pros
- Secure, non-slip surface
- Durable Delrin material
- Easy-to-spot bright green color
Cons
- Limited thickness options
- May be too slick for some players
- Slightly pricier than basic picks
These Ernie Ball Everlast picks feel fantastic in your hand. The Delrin material gives you a secure grip, so they stay put, even during long sessions. At 0.88mm, they’re flexible but still offer good control, which makes them great for both strumming and lead playing. And that bright green color? It’s super handy on stage if you drop one!
Durability is a big plus here. We put these picks through weeks of heavy use, and they still look almost new. While they’re a bit more expensive than basic picks, the long-lasting quality makes up for it.
The non-slip surface is a standout feature. Even with sweaty hands, these picks stayed steady. Though if you prefer a rougher texture, you might find them a bit too smooth.
Overall, we’re big fans of the Everlast picks. They combine comfort, durability, and performance really well. If you’re looking to upgrade from standard picks, give these a try and you won’t be disappointed.
Dunlop Jazz III XL Picks
If you’re after more control and precision, the Dunlop Jazz III XL picks are a game-changer.
Pros
- Larger size for better grip
- Sharp tip for extra accuracy
- Durable nylon material
Cons
- May be too thick for some playing styles
- Takes a bit of time to get used to the size
- Limited color options
The Dunlop Jazz III XL feel like the classic Jazz III, but with a little more to hold onto, and honestly, that makes a big difference.
The larger grip is fantastic. It gives you extra control, especially during fast solos or intricate riffs. And the sharp tip lets you hit every note with serious precision.
At 1.5mm thick, these picks have a solid feel and bring out a full, rich tone, which is perfect for rock and metal. They also have just enough flexibility for smooth strumming, so they work well across different styles.
The bright red color is a bonus. It’s easy to spot on stage if you drop one, and the molded texture helps it stay put in your fingers, even when things get sweaty.
If you’re switching from thinner picks, there might be a little adjustment period. But once you get the hang of it, you’ll probably wonder how you ever played without these. They cost a bit more than the basics, but with the quality you’re getting, they’re worth every penny.
Dava Delrin Grip Tips
If you’re looking for a pick that gives you comfort, control, and durability all in one, the Dava Delrin Grip Tips are definitely worth checking out.
Pros
- Multi-gauge flexibility
- Excellent grip and control
- Durable Delrin material
Cons
- Pricier than standard picks
- May take time to adjust to
- Limited color options
What’s really cool about the Dava Delrin Grip Tips is how easily you can switch between a softer and firmer feel just by adjusting your grip. If you hold closer to the tip, you get a firmer touch, and if you loosen up a bit, you get a softer sound. It feels like having several picks in one.
The Delrin material is super smooth, which makes playing faster and more natural. It glides over the strings with ease, giving you great control whether you are strumming chords or picking leads. And the rubber grip? It is a game-changer. You will not have to worry about slipping, even when your hands get a bit sweaty.
These picks are also built to last. We have put them through lots of playing, and they have held up impressively well. The pack of six is handy, but honestly, with the secure grip, we rarely lose them. The slightly higher price is well worth it for the quality and versatility they offer.
D’Addario Celluloid Picks
If you’re looking for a pick with a warm tone and a classic feel, the D’Addario Celluloid picks are a great choice.
Pros
- Natural feel and warm tone
- Versatile for strumming and picking
- Durable celluloid material
Cons
- Limited thickness options
- May be slippery for some players
- Not the most eco-friendly material
The D’Addario Celluloid picks are versatile enough for just about anything. The 0.70mm medium gauge hits a sweet spot for most playing styles.
The tone these picks produce is warm and full, which works well on both acoustic and electric guitars. They have a natural feel that makes long practice sessions comfortable, so you can play for hours without feeling fatigued.
One thing to keep in mind is that celluloid can be a bit slick. If you’re used to a more textured pick, it might take a little adjustment.
These picks are great for both strumming and picking. They have just enough flexibility for smooth strumming but are still firm enough to give clear, defined single-note lines.
The standard shape is easy to hold and control, and the assorted colors in each pack add a fun touch. It’s a nice little detail that makes playing even more enjoyable.
While celluloid isn’t the most eco-friendly material, these picks hold up well. We’ve been using some of ours for months, and they’re still in great shape.
For the price, you’re getting a solid set of 10 picks that will serve you well across different genres. They’re a staple in our gig bag and studio.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Guitar Pick
Choosing the right guitar pick can really make a difference in how you play. Let’s break down some of the key things to consider to help you find the perfect pick for your style.
Pick Material Options
There are a bunch of different materials for picks, each with its own vibe and sound.
- Nylon: Nylon picks are flexible and have a warm, mellow tone. They’re great if you’re into softer styles, and they feel really comfortable in your hand.
- Celluloid: If you like a brighter tone, celluloid picks are a solid choice. They have a nice, crisp attack and that classic pick look, though they may not last as long as some other materials.
- Delrin (like Tortex): These are our top choice for durability and a balanced tone. They work well across styles like rock and jazz and always give a consistent sound.
- Ultex: Ultex picks are super tough and hold their shape. They give a bright, clear tone that cuts through nicely, making them a great choice for live performances.
- Acrylic: Acrylic picks are glossy and rigid, which gives them a high-definition tone that sounds amazing in recordings.
Thickness and Flexibility
The thickness of a pick affects how it sounds and how it feels in your hand.
- Thin picks (under 0.6mm): These are flexible and give a bright, lively tone that’s perfect for strumming acoustic guitars.
- Medium picks (0.6mm to 0.8mm): Medium picks are versatile and work well for both strumming and picking. They’re a good choice if you like to mix things up.
- Heavy picks (0.8mm to 1.2mm): Heavier picks have less flex and a warmer tone. They’re ideal for lead playing and for those single-note lines.
- Extra heavy picks (over 1.2mm): These are super rigid and give you a lot of control, which is perfect for fast and precise playing in metal or jazz.
In general, thicker picks give you more control, while thinner picks are usually easier for beginners to handle.
Shape and Size
Different pick shapes can make a difference in how you play, so it’s worth trying a few to see what feels best.
- Standard 351: This is the classic shape that’s comfortable and versatile, so it’s great for all-around use.
- Jazz III: These are smaller with a sharp tip, which is ideal for fast, precise playing. They’re perfect if you like to play lead.
- Teardrop: Teardrop picks fit nicely between your fingers and give you more control, which makes them great for intricate parts.
- Triangle: Triangle picks have a larger surface area, making them easy to hold. They work well for bass and rhythm guitar.
The shape of your pick can affect both your speed and your accuracy, so it’s worth experimenting until you find one that feels right.
Grip and Texture
We can’t stress enough how important grip is, especially for long sessions or when you’re playing live.
- Textured surfaces: A textured surface with raised patterns can really help keep the pick from slipping.
- Rubberized coatings: These add extra grip, which is super helpful if your hands get sweaty.
- Picks with holes: Picks with holes can give you a better hold, so they’re less likely to slip from your hand.
A secure grip helps you stay comfortable and in control, which is important for hitting those tricky parts just right.
Finding the perfect pick can bring out the best in your playing, so don’t be afraid to try out a few different styles and materials until you find the one that feels and sounds just right for you.
Final Thoughts
We’ve talked about a lot of great guitar picks, but remember, there’s no single pick that works for everyone. The best one for you really depends on your style and what feels good in your hand.
If you need a starting point, try the Dunlop Tortex Standard .73mm Yellow pick. It’s versatile and reliable, so it’s hard to go wrong with it. And if you’re looking for something more budget-friendly, the D’Addario Celluloid picks give you great value without compromising on quality.
Most importantly, don’t hesitate to experiment. Try out different materials, thicknesses, and shapes. You might be surprised by what fits your style and sounds great on your guitar.
Picks are small, but they make a big difference in your sound. Grab a variety and see which ones bring out the best in your playing.
In the end, the best pick is the one that feels comfortable and helps you play your best. Keep exploring, and have fun finding your perfect match. Happy playing!
For other essential guitar gear, check out these guides on beginner guitar strings, electric guitar strings, guitar cables, guitar tuners, guitar straps, guitar cases, guitar stands, guitar slides, and guitar chairs.
Frequently Asked Questions About Guitar Picks
What picks do most guitarists use?
A lot of guitarists go for medium-thickness picks. Some of the most popular are Dunlop Tortex and Fender 351 Shape picks because they work great on both electric and acoustic guitars. They’re durable and give you a nice balance of tone and flexibility, so it’s easy to see why so many people love them.
What guitar picks do the pros use?
Pro guitarists usually choose picks that match their own style. For example, Eric Johnson and John Petrucci love the Dunlop Jazz III because it’s so precise. Kirk Hammett even has his own version of the Jazz III that’s made for shredding. Chris Thile, on the other hand, uses a casein pick to get a clear, warm tone on his acoustic. Pros focus on the pick’s material, thickness, and shape to get the exact sound they want.
Why do some guitarists use different picks for different songs or styles?
Picks can really change up the tone and feel of a song. Jazz and metal players, for instance, might prefer thick, sharp picks for precise notes, while folk and rock rhythm players often go for thinner, more flexible picks for smoother strumming. Changing picks helps us get the exact sound or feel we want for each song. Different styles just need different picks.
What thickness of pick is best for beginners?
If you’re just starting out, medium-thickness picks, usually around 0.6mm to 0.8mm, are a solid choice. They give you a good mix of flexibility and control, making them nice for both strumming and picking. Trying a few different thicknesses is a great way to find what feels right. Medium picks are a perfect starting point for exploring different styles.
Which is better: fingerpicking or using a pick?
Both fingerpicking and using a pick have their own advantages. Fingerpicking lets you control each note individually and creates a soft, detailed sound, which works well for folk, classical, and jazz. A pick, on the other hand, gives you a brighter, punchier tone that’s ideal for rock, metal, and pop. It all depends on the music style you’re playing and what you like best.
How often should I replace my guitar pick?
How long a pick lasts depends on its material and how often you play. Most of us replace a pick when it starts sounding dull or shows visible wear. If you play a lot, you might need to replace your picks more often. Nylon picks tend to wear out quicker than Ultex or Delrin ones. Keep an eye on the edges and the grip. When they start affecting your sound or feel, it’s time for a new pick.